If we described a particular investment product as having a coupon that can shift around based on market forces, having a potentially unlimited lifetime and having embedded call options many investors would think we are talking about some sort of highly complex institutional derivative. However, we just described a pretty basic preferred stock. Despite the fact that preferreds are very popular with individual investors doesn’t make them any less complex instruments. This complexity is particularly relevant now that Libor – the base rate for most Fix/Float preferreds – has begun to lift off in anticipation of a sequence of Fed policy rate hikes.
This, along with the fact that 1) many preferreds will come to their first call date soon and, hence, the start of their floating coupon periods and 2) many will be unredeemed as their coupons will step down highlights the fact that investors should start to seriously think about the yields on their Fix/Float holdings after the end of the non-call period.
The chart below compares current fixed-rate coupons to the Libor-based reset coupons of these stocks. Reset coupons are basically derived from Libor forwards or market expectations of Libor on the first call date. For example, a stock with a fixed coupon of 6.5% today which switches to a coupon equal to 3-month Libor + 4% at the end of 2022 and trades at $24 will have a reset yield of 6.19% since Libor is expected to be around 1.94% by the end of the year.
What is clear is that the vast majority of stocks will very likely see a stepdown in coupons based on current Libor market expectations. Of course, it is possible that 1) some of these stocks will be redeemed or 2) Libor will rise above current market expectations but as things stand now, it is our expectation that most stocks will remain outstanding given the stepdown in coupons and a difficult refinancing environment for issuers. The chart below compares current and reset coupons of Libor Fix/Float stocks that are expected to switch to a floating-rate coupon within the next two years.
What can investors do? One option, as usual, is to do nothing. It is not entirely unreasonable to say that the expected step-down in coupons is more-or-less priced into markets today and that the higher yields up to the first call date of Fix/Float preferreds is simply a kind of balancing-out of a lower yield to come.
For example, we can see this by comparing the yield-to-worst of four CIM preferreds, one of which is fixed-rate (CIM.PA) with the other three Fix/Float. The fact that all three Fix/Float stocks trade at higher yields up to their call date than CIM.PA could just be a fair-value reflection of their coming step-down in yields. In short, investors are compensated today for the likely drop in yield to come in the future, net net leaving them square.
We are sympathetic to this argument, however, it is also our view that the broader preferreds market is not as universally efficient as this example may imply. Specifically, there are opportunities between Fix/Float preferreds of the same issuer as well as between Fix/Float series between issuers.
Let’s see how investors can identify these opportunities. Let’s use the three NLY preferreds as a case study – they are summarized below with a screenshot from our investor Preferreds Tool.
Now let’s plot, what we call, forward yields of these stocks relative to each other.
This is how forward yields work. Up to the first call date (marked with a black dot) the yield of a given stock is just the yield-to-worst. The yield-to-worst is the minimum of stripped yield and yield-to-first-call – a pretty standard way of dealing with the yield of a callable security up to its first call date.
For example, for NLY.PF, the stripped yield is 7.2% while the yield-to-call is 14.1%, hence the yield-to-worst is 7.2%.
After the first call date the yield of the stock is just the expected Libor (i.e. Libor forward) on that date plus the spread over Libor, divided by the stripped i.e. clean price x liquidation preference. For example, the reset yield of NLY.PF on its first call date 30-Sep-22 is (Libor forward of 1.62% + spread over Libor of 4.993%) / current stripped price $24.07 x liquidation preference $25 = 6.87%.
Each subsequent quarter the coupon will shift based on the evolution of Libor forwards which looks like the following as of this writing. Libor forwards update daily just as “normal” or par interest rates do since they are just a function of current interest rates. The geeks in the audience can learn all about bootstrapping forward rates here.
If we go back to the chart we see that, except for the initial blip lower on its first call date, the NLY.PF forward yield tends to trade above the yields of the other two series which is why it is the series that looks most attractive to us.
There is a small chance of a redemption on the first call date and it’s something investors ought to keep in the back of their minds, however, even here NLY.PF looks close to the best. NLY.PF does have less call protection, however, in our view it is fairly likely to remain outstanding past its first call date and, it seems, given its below-“par” price this is what the market expects as well.
Obviously, investors may have a different view on the trajectory of Libor than what is implied by the market, however, a comparison of forward yields like we described here is a good starting place.
Check out more in-depth and timely commentary as well as Income Portfolios and interactive Investor Tools at our Premium service.
ADS Analytics LLC / Systematic Income provides opinions regarding securities and other related topics on an impersonal basis; therefore no consideration is made towards your individual financial circumstances.
All content presented here is not to be regarded as investment advice or constitute a client / advisor relationship. It is for general informational purpose only.
Trading securities involves risk, so you must always use your own best judgment when trading securities. You assume the entire cost and risk of any trading you choose to undertake. You are completely responsible for making any investment decisions.