Are You Following These Bad BDC Investment Strategies?

In this brief post we highlight a couple of BDC allocation strategies that appear to be common but are unlikely to outperform in the longer-term in our view.

One strategy is what is commonly called a value trap strategy that allocates to BDCs primarily on the basis of valuation. For instance, a recent headline stated that the BlackRock Capital Investment Corp (BKCC) is an “average” BDC at a cheap valuation.

In fact, there is nothing average about BKCC when we look at its ability to generate wealth for investors. It is the worst performer across 3Y and 5Y horizons in total NAV return terms of the BDCs in our coverage.

Systematic Income

Granted, gauging total NAV returns can be quite tricky in the BDC sector which is why you don’t often hear about it in BDC commentary but it’s essential to avoid value traps like BKCC.

The other strategy that is likely to underperform in our view, though to a smaller extent, is buying strong-performers without regard to valuation. The problem here isn’t that these BDCs deliver poor total NAV return – they typically outperform the sector. However, their elevated valuation is totally out of line with how much outperformance they have delivered in total NAV terms historically.

For example, BDCs like CSWC and HRZN spent much of 2021 trading at silly valuations of 150-170% which was around 40-60% above the sector average.

Systematic Income

This is despite delivering performance that was only 0-20% above the sector average level over the past 3-5 years in total NAV terms (and lower more recently).

Systematic Income

In short, once valuation is taken into account, these BDCs typically deliver a lower return on investor capital than the sector average. Higher-valuation BDCs also tend to be priced for perfection and see significant valuation compression in periods when not everything lines up perfectly, such as 2022.

In our view, avoiding value traps and making sure that the valuation investors pay are justified by a similarly high or even higher total NAV outperformance can increase the likelihood of investors reaching their investment goals in the sector.

Check out more in-depth and timely commentary as well as Income Portfolios and interactive Investor Tools at our Premium service.

ADS Analytics LLC / Systematic Income provides opinions regarding securities and other related topics on an impersonal basis; therefore no consideration is made towards your individual financial circumstances.

All content presented here is not to be regarded as investment advice or constitute a client / advisor relationship. It is for general informational purpose only.

Trading securities involves risk, so you must always use your own best judgment when trading securities. You assume the entire cost and risk of any trading you choose to undertake. You are completely responsible for making any investment decisions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.